Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Dallas Cowboys Projects: Andre Holmes

The concussion discussion



There is something that has been bothering for about two years now with the NHL trying to crackdown on concussions. Lately I've paying attention to little details about the pictures Yahoo! puts up everyday (as that's where i go to  watch the box scores) and a cause of this concussion problem has been jumping at my face every day: More and more players do not wear their helmets properly. I'm not going to post a bunch of pictures because frankly I haven't done it and I gotta get to bed so I'm not about to try and figure it out, however I just looked up in game pics of 7 players. Joe Sakic, Forsberg, Raymond B., Rob Blake, Paul Kariya, Crosby, and Malkin. Super Joe, Foppa, Ray, Blake, and Malkin all had one thing in common: Tight chin straps. Yes during warm up pics some of them had their straps loose but once game time came they tightened their straps. Now Kariya (lost track after 9 concussions) and Crosby (welcome back, but I still hate you...and you are ugly) is different. During game time their straps are loose. Crosby's is ridiculously so. I mean you can fit 4 fingers in his strap.

Now I know a helmet will not prevent all concussions. I just got a mild one last week being hit on the cheek with a bottle of Wheat Germ. However, It is my belief that if a rule was to be instituted about chin straps we'd see at least a 40% decrease in concussions. Now I know many of you stat people are thinking: "40%? Prove it!" Let me say now, 40% is my estimate, its not scientific and I will not prove it.

I do find it very alarming that if you scan through recent game day pics on sports sites that more and more players aren't tightening their chin straps. This will lead to more concussions from double impacts. First impact and then the second impact when the helmet moves or flies off.

So my thinking is to institute a ten minute game misconduct penalty for improper safety gear (OSHA's everywhere else for crying out loud) and a fine when refs see players on the ice during games with loose chin straps. Doing this would make the stars care more about their safety so they don't get booted from games but it wouldn't effect play with a power play or anything and a simple fine doesn't mean much to someone making 11 mil a year. I mean, you never know, if Crosby cared about wearing his helmet properly would he have been concussed? Why has no one in the hockey media even brought up that his first game back he was playing with his ever present , ridiculously loose chin strap?

I think its a possible solution to a big problem that will not force them to make more changes to the game. What say you?

Poll
Save heads and the game by instituting a 10 minute game misconduct penalty for improper wearing of helmets?
Yes, It doesn't affect the game but forces players to take accountability for their safety
10 votes
No, Its the hits that are the biggest problem and the game needs some tweaks
4 votes

14 votes | Poll has closed

MileHighHockey.com is a fan community, allowing members to post their own thoughts and opinions on the Colorado Avalanche and hockey in general. These views and thoughts may not be shared by the editors of MileHighHockey.com.

Comment 6 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

10 minute game seems a bit harsh. I would rather see that penalty for turning face first into the boards right before a check is delivered.

by avalanchejef on Nov 22, 2011 2:26 PM MST reply actions  

Something needs to be done, for sure. There are two things that can help prevent concussion:

1). Wearing a helmet with the chinstrap done tight.
2). Wearing a mouthshield

Too many times, I have seen mouthshield being chewed on (during play, for crissakes!) and loose straps which just mean that the helmet is going to come off in an impact, thereby totally negating wearing a helmet.

The league has done something by mandating seamed glass, which I think has helped the Avs this year, but they need to go further by implementing either deformable armour (which would break upon really hard impact) or softer pads.

I would also mandate Mark Messier’s helmets throughout the league. If it even gives a 10% boost in protection, it has to be worth it.

"Wisdom requires a flexible mind" - Dan Carlin

by Nemesis44UK on Nov 23, 2011 2:38 AM MST reply actions  

Completely agree with the helmet being donned tightly, however reports differ as to whether mouthguards have any effect in the prevention of concussions.

by Tvm950 on Nov 24, 2011 2:10 PM MST up reply actions  

This has been discussed before, so you're definitely onto something.

Thought food: if Joe Sacco is fired, Sylvain Lefebvre will be the Avs' new head coach. Think about it.

The 2011-2012 Colorado Avalanche: there will be blood and there will be wins.

"God I'm excited for those two to fail miserably." - SBNation writer Andrew Sharp on Josh McDaniels and Tim Tebow.

The Number Zero, for everything but mathematics. Blood and Thunder Record: 8-10-1 (Total Record: 9-14-1)

by Tempestuous Binary on Nov 23, 2011 3:53 AM MST reply actions  

I just saw a talk by an engineer doing research into hockey impacts.

And he agrees with you; one of the biggest problems with concussions in hockey right now is the poor chin strap use.

They also need to stop play when helmets come off. They already do this for the goalies, and they absolutely should do it for players.

Here’s an idea: if your helmet comes off, play stops and the faceoff comes back into your defensive zone, no matter where play was stopped. That would (hopefully) force players to put on their chin straps tightly.

by ExiledAmongYou on Nov 25, 2011 10:30 AM MST reply actions  

I remember reading some years ago about mouth pieces helping keep the jaw stable. And that many concussions weren’t due to a a blow to the head per se as much as it was related to jaw trauma. So i definitely think a tight chin strap coupled with a proper mouthpiece would help decrease concussions dramatically.

In unison: "Wonder twin powers Activate!" Varly: "Form of Goal"; Giggy: "Shape of Tending."

by tat2dpunk on Nov 29, 2011 11:55 AM MST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

For original fans of the Quebec Nordiques, transplanted fans of the Colorado Rockies, day one fans of the Avalanche and bandwagon fans just looking for a place to root.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Oak_bigger_small
Favorite non-Avs players
Oak_bigger_small
Bracket Challenge, half way there...
Russia4_small
Landeskog on Varly at Worlds
Steamavatar_small
Relish in the decline of the RedWheel
Steamavatar_small
Lets play fill the hole
Russia4_small
WC: Russia vs Norway
Small
MORE of My Investigative Report
Russia4_small
Varly answers fan questions at Worlds
2309379311_5dd939250e_o_small
Why the CBA argument is a red herring
Oak_bigger_small
MHH Bracket Challenge

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

View My Stats

Managing Editor

Milehigh-xl_small David Driscoll-Carignan

Assistant Editors

Icon_small Joe Dunman

Mike_logo_2_small Mike @ MHH

148488_10150337054485417_836355416_16934526_6679165_n_small Sandie Gauthier

Gravatar_small Cheryl Bradley

Staff Writers

Me2_small Angélique C. Murray

Godzilla_mario_small A.J. Haefele

Me_small Derek B

Me_and_fopps_small Cole D Hamilton

I3_r_3___t_small Brett Shumway

Wilson_small Randy Time

Zaphod_small SteveHouse

Avalanche_logo_small andidee15

Jtizz_small Sean Harsha